Substantial Progress On Cervical Check Following Review

Cervical Check Scandal - Independent Check - Dr. Gabriel Scally

Dr Gabriel Scally has reviewed his 2018 report into the controversy which saw over 200 women not told of abnormalities found in their smear test results during an audit

Publishing his review of the progress that has been made in implementing over 50 CervicalCheck recommendations, Dr Scally called for the introduction of open disclosure in the healthcare system and hit out at hurtful attitudes “which are still prevalent“.

He said today that patients want the truth, an apology, and to know it won’t happen again if something goes wrong in their treatment.

Dr Scally said proposed laws will only apply to a “tiny proportion” or patient incidents.

All healthcare professionals should have a duty when things go wrong to deal with them in an open manner and with the grace and compassion they deserve.”

He suggested that amendments have watered down the Patient Safety (Notifiable Patient Safety Incidents) Bill, which was originally introduced in 2019 but has yet to be enacted.

The limited scope of the Bill is problematic. The Bill only specifies the mandatory requirement for open disclosure in the case of 13 categories of incidents. 12 out of the 13 highly specific incidents where notification would be mandatory relate to the death of a patient. This, under any circumstances, represents a tiny proportion of harm caused to patients through clinical error.

The enactment of a statutory duty of candour on individual healthcare professionals and on the organisations for which they work remains unaddressed,” Dr Scally said.

He added that he is “very disappointed” by the way in which patient representatives and advocates continue to be treated.

It is ridiculous that people are having to damage their own businesses or their relationship with their employer or the use our own time and their own resources to enable them to contribute to the collective good because that’s what they’re there for to help us build a better health service for the population and they need to be recompensed for the time,” he said.

The campaigning work done by Vicky Phelan, and others, forced the Government to set up an inquiry into what happened to the women affected by CervicalCheck.

Ms Phelan passed away earlier this month at the age of 48.

She grabbed the attention of the public in 2018 after bringing a High Court case over how her cervical smears tests were handled.